Mr. President, one of Cramer's convictions is that not every transaction requires a loser.
Too often in this town, however, our success is measured by how badly we defeat our competitors rather than how much we produce for our constituents. What it is we actually deliver, not defeat, should be the standard.
One of the best opportunities that I have seen in my 14 years in Congress for us to actually deliver something significant to our constituents is well within our reach. It is right in front of us. And that, of course, is permitting reform.
For decades, the process of approving the building of the infrastructure necessary to meet the demands of a growing and dynamic economy have been mired in partisan politics and an out-of-control bureaucracy, which limits our Nation's potential, our prosperity, and stifles our global competitiveness.
The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act is an opportunity for us to turn that corner, and it is imperative that we do it now while the window is open.
Whether it is transmission lines to load centers, pipelines to refineries, steel mills and drone factories, or family housing, we must secure durable changes to the Federal permitting process or continue to fall behind our global competitors.
We must make it easier to build in America. China, for example, dominates global manufacturing, particularly in those industries that are indispensable to our national defense. For example, China's steel production exceeds ours by roughly--get this now--12 to 1. In shipbuilding, China possesses capacity roughly 230 times that of the United States. Let me say that again. With regard to shipbuilding--very important to our economy, obviously, and important to our national defense--China possesses capacity roughly 230 times that of the United States. A single major Chinese shipyard can exceed the total output of the entire U.S. commercial shipbuilding industry.
Regarding infrastructure, well, a recent report put out by McKinsey & Company paints a stark--very stark--picture full of opportunities. McKinsey's report on the economic impact of Federal permitting delays highlights the massive scale of capital and economic activity that is stalled in the United States “permitting pipeline,” if you excuse the expression.
According to McKinsey's report, U.S. Federal permitting holds, get this now, $1.8 trillion--with a “t”--$1.8 trillion in infrastructure projects, and better than that, $1.1 trillion of it is private sector money.
In my State of North Dakota, $24 billion sits on the sidelines while the bureaucracy holds development hostage.
These delays represent over $3 trillion in cumulative unrealized economic activity.
The priority sectors account for roughly 40 percent of total construction spend--$899 billion, actually, out of $2.17 trillion--led by manufacturing, $330 billion; transportation, $215 billion; oil and gas extraction, $114 billion; broadband and telecom, another $101 billion; electricity generation, $63 billion; electric transmission--we are going to talk a lot about that--$38 billion; and mining and oil-gas pipelines, $19 billion each.
Absolute investment delays, according to McKinsey, are concentrated in large States for sure, like Texas, California, Florida, and New York, while relative economic exposure peaks in States like Wyoming, Alaska, North Dakota, New Mexico, and West Virginia.
Permitting delays, in addition to all of that, trigger roughly 5 percent annual cost increases. So delays cost money, they reduce income availability, and they actually drive prices up.
But the good news--the good news--is that we are on the brink of reversing those negatives and using the opportunities to put Americans to work building things right here--building things right here in the United States. This bill is an opportunity to create winners all around. Both sides of the proverbial political aisle are tired of the regulatory whiplash from one administration to the next.
Another one of Cramer's convictions is that nothing brings people together like a common adversary.
Earlier this year, the Environment and Public Works Committee held a hearing on permitting reform. We had excellent technical witnesses--I think it was about five of them--with great knowledge and great experience they were bringing to the discussion.
Ironically or perhaps not so ironically, it was the Senators who did most of the talking, taking turns sharing their grievances about how Presidents of the opposing political party were blocking their State's projects--in many cases after the projects were permitted and in some, actually completed. In some cases, it was a wind or solar project; in others, it was a pipeline or a liquid natural gas terminal.
I leaned over to ranking member Senator Whitehouse, and I said: Sheldon, we should just stipulate that we don't like Presidents from the other party who kill our projects.
But remember, nothing brings people together like a common adversary.
The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act--or BAAJA, as we like to call it--hits that nail right on the head. It is the kind of bill where everyone across the political spectrum gets enough of what they want. They may not get everything they want, but they get enough to claim victory--no losers.
I believe the most consequential parts of BAAJA deal with judicial reforms. Challenges to the National Environmental Policy Act--a.k.a. NEPA--Clean Water Act, and the National Historic Preservation Act must be filed within 150 days rather than the 6-year window they are now. That is what our bill does. It takes 6 years and turns it into 150 days--6 years down to 150 days.
Think about that for a minute. A project can be built and operational. Yet, as of now, a litigant can file years later and throw that road, bridge, pipeline, or transmission line into doubt. We have experienced that phenomenon in North Dakota.
Also under our bill, legal challenges can only come from those who raised the issue during the comment period and then--get this--can actually show direct harm. Did you know that before, they didn't have to show harm? They could just--anybody could sue. In other words, law firms cannot simply create a cottage industry exploiting would-be victims because their feelings are hurt.
If a court finds a problem, the Agency needs to fix it within 180 days rather than just being forced to just vacate and start the whole project over, as is often the case when activist and activist judges look to block the projects. In other words, to try to throw a legal wrench in the process, someone must have skin in the game.
NEPA has been weaponized for decades by extreme activists who simply want to obstruct projects. NEPA is a procedural statute, according to the Supreme Court, not substantive. It is designed to make sure Agencies consider all of the options before green-lighting a project. On average, this process takes roughly 4 years and often much, much longer than that--twice as long as that or more. That will stop under this bill. It gets back to the intent of NEPA--to consider informed alternatives and green-light the best, most workable option. We are going to get back to building, not balking.
Analysis from the Council of Economic Advisers found that reducing NEPA environmental impact statement review times to 2 years from that 4 to 8 to 10 actually increases annual tax revenue by $14 billion to $28 billion--increases the revenue to the coffers of the government simply by bringing the review time down to 2 years--and it increases real wages by $306 to $637 per year for the average household, OK? So it increases tax revenue, increases wages, and reduces electricity bills by $178 to $251 per year for the average household. Wow. It gets better. More revenue for the government, higher wages for the worker, and lower electricity bills for the consumer. And we often say around here that energy security is national security, and this legislation certainly helps secure North Dakota energy production and energy production in every State.
I submit to you that permitting reform is also essential for our national security. As a nation, we cannot build and we cannot produce at the rates necessary to counter adversaries like China, which builds three times as fast as we do at a fraction of the cost.
Now, I wouldn't trade governments with China for anything. The COVID pandemic highlighted the risks, however, within our supply chains. We need to mine our own rare earth and critical minerals where we have them and onshore our pharmaceutical production where we may not have the ingredients.
Our defense industrial base must be able to grow at a speed necessary to deter our adversaries and allow us, the United States, to prevail should we end up in a major conflict. These are no-fail missions over which we can never allow ourselves to be held hostage by an outsized bureaucracy.
Now, this bill nearly perfectly encapsulates what it takes to negotiate a true bipartisan product. It is a balance. It has balance.
Take electric transmission for example. Given my experience as a former utility regulator, I have advocated for caution and even blocked previous attempts to overhaul electricity policy. Is the transaction section what I would have written if I were the King? It is not. But I am not the King. But the bill is an improvement over prior versions, and it strikes enough of a balance for me to get behind it given all of the other provisions particularly of the bill.
The vast majority of this body has rallied around this bill because it provides certainty for everyone. Oil producers in North Dakota and Alaska and offshore wind projects in Rhode Island will benefit just as much as manufacturers and roads and bridges from coast to coast.
Achieving true balance is undeniably elusive. In fact, it is darn rare, even in the Senate, where we depend on consensus. Achieving true balance, though, should be the goal. Finding balance at the right time, however, is even harder. We have an open window to pass this generational legislation to empower the people who make things in America, but the window will close soon, to likely not open again for a very long time, if ever.
Further evidence of the policy balance that this bill strikes is the breadth of support that only a truly bipartisan bill could enjoy. It is supported by investor-owned utilities, rural electric cooperatives, the White House, renewable energy groups, oil and gas producers, manufacturers, labor organizations, miners, farm groups, and many, many more. In fact, the diverse coalition of people lined up behind this bill is proof enough of the major work that has been done to reach this consensus.
By the way, consensus is not just gravitating to the lowest common denominator and claiming immunity. No. The policy victories claimed by all sides in this incredible work product demonstrate deep convictions, even some redlines that could not be crossed, but it also includes some low-hanging fruit and some really hard-to-reach compromise. It involved fits and starts, moments when it would have been easier to simply throw up your hands and walk away. It involved late nights for staffers whose names you may never hear or know and meetings with allies right after the meeting with negotiators and back to the allies and the usual back-and-forth in a negotiating process, helping stakeholders feel comfortable with the progress and the process.
It took uncommon leadership, and I am grateful. I am grateful for my colleagues who worked tirelessly, mostly cheerfully, for the last year to get us to this point.
Most importantly, thank you, Environment and Public Works chair Shelley Moore Capito and ranking member Sheldon Whitehouse.
I said to both of them this morning that they might be the only two Senators who tolerate each other. Because they have been through this, they are better partners than ever.
Thank you, Energy and National Resources chair Mike Lee and ranking member Martin Heinrich, for hanging in there.
Guys, I am telling you, I know this stuff. The nerdy stuff these two had to work through would cause lesser people to throw in the towel. The work of these four leaders and a host of others is what results in a law that is as durable as it is balanced. And what is the point of making laws that aren't durable?
A special thank-you also goes to the President's team at the White House. President Trump and his Energy Dominance Council are on board with a bill that, frankly, defers a significant amount of Executive power. Presidents don't give that up easily. But their constructive engagement is greatly appreciated.
So now lets get the job done. Lets pass the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, send it to the House with a lot of momentum, restore certainty in the Federal permitting process, and build and produce in America as though our country depends on it because today, our country depends on us.
I yield the floor.