Mr. Speaker, I ask unanimous consent that all Members may have 5 legislative days in which to revise and extend their remarks and include extraneous material on the subject of my Special Order today.
Mr. Speaker, the subject of the Special Order hour today is about our veterans, the men and women who served our Nation and military.
It is fitting that on the 11th of November, a day we call Veterans Day--a tradition that began in the wake of World War I, the 11th hour of the 11th day of the 11th month--we use this day to remember the sacrifices of the people who sacrificed for us.
It is with a mixture of reverence for their service, but also, because of the events today, I am angry. I am sad. I am confused by what I feel is the unjust and unfair way that the majority has conducted themselves with regard to how this Chamber works.
I am trying to contain and make sure that my anger does not explode to the extent that I will say things I will regret.
But my deepest regret is that on this day, of all days, on Veterans Day, we would have seen, but for the distractions, the decoys that the majority used to distract and to put forward and move forward through a specious voice vote, the Taking Care of America's Veterans Act, which in reality is an ironic title.
There is nothing really about this act that takes care of veterans. It is the largest cut to veterans' benefits in the history of the United States.
The way that the majority contrived to push this bill through was to use decoys in a decoy way, the floor staff, to negotiate technical changes to the bill that we were supposed to agree to on unanimous consent, and while this was happening, they very quietly put forward a vote on TCAVA.
Subsequently, there was no opportunity for the minority to ask for its right for a recorded vote. There was no opportunity later for the majority to grant that vote. As a result, there has been no accountability for the Members of this Chamber to take responsibility for what they would have voted on on TCAVA.
For a bill that was supposed to be so good for veterans, I don't understand why there would have been an eagerness to be recorded as an “aye” vote. But, alas, this was not their intention. Their intention was not to have an open vote, a roll call vote. Their intention was to sneak this through.
Well, all I can say is I think it is a shallow and hollow victory because it will go nowhere in the Senate. Why? Because veterans service organizations across the country have made clear their opposition to the Taking Care of America's Veterans Act, TCAVA. They have made clear that the largest cut to veterans' benefits in history is simply not acceptable.
It is disgraceful that they pushed through this bill in the way that they did on today, of all days.
Today, of all days, Mr. Speaker, the majority has pushed through the largest cut to veterans' benefits in history, all the while our men and women in uniform are on bases around Iran, subject to drone attacks, and subject to the explosions and the blasts.
What this majority did is push through a bill that would say that those men and women in uniform will not be able to make claims of hearing loss or another condition that is associated with traumatic brain injury and PTSD, which is sleep apnea. These are two of the most prevalent conditions that veterans make claims on.
The Republican majority has said, in its infinite wisdom, that these servicemembers who are serving right now will not be able to make claims for those conditions so that they can “save” $57 billion.
I say this is a hollow victory. It is very shallow. It is despicable that the floor tactics that were used today have resulted in this hollow victory.
But what remains is the work of the whole Democratic Caucus and a few Republicans who were willing to sign the discharge petition. I will note that the discharge petition, the motion to discharge, the Major Richard Star Act, was debated this morning, with 33 Republicans joining all the Democrats in voting for that motion to discharge in order to bring the Richard Star Act to the floor.
That was an indication to me that TCAVA was on a pathway this afternoon to sure and certain failure.
This is, I think, very clear evidence of why the Republican majority was motivated to do what it did today, which is to use really treacherous and devious floor tactics to achieve their ends.
I do not think that they are proud of TCAVA, otherwise they would have been eager to call for the floor vote themselves. That happens all the time.
They should have been proud on Veterans Day to tout the centerpiece legislation on veterans. But they know that too many of their side, too many of their Members were not going to vote for this.
[Material placed in the Record (such as bill text, a letter or an article) is not shown here. See the original.]
In fact, this very same legislation at the beginning of the summer had to be pulled twice because they did not have the votes. Since the bill was already debated and because it had been pulled, it could be brought to the House floor at any moment.
In fact, in an unprecedented way, they dropped this bill today. Many would call it an audible. In football, there is such a thing as an audible, where there is a change in formation and play. The quarterback calls it. That is what the Speaker and his team did, a last-minute audible, because their plan all the time was to sneak this bill through.
As I said, this bill will not get through the Senate. They could not even get enough votes here in the House that would say publicly that they would vote for this bill.
By contrast, the Major Richard Star Act had over 330 cosponsors. This Republican House contrived all sorts of ways to keep the Major Richard Star Act from getting to a vote.
That is why I undertook the effort to get a discharge petition circulated. A few weeks ago, that petition reached 218 signatures. On Monday, I made notice that I would be making a motion today. I gave notice 2 days ago, and that has set up the debate for tomorrow.
We will be debating the Major Richard Star Act tomorrow, and I expect that there will be broad support, that we will see a huge bipartisan vote on the record--on the record--and I will be happy myself to call for the yeas and nays.
Mr. Speaker, I am very sad to see our institution be operated by people who will stoop to such low tactics, especially on Veterans Day, regarding veteran legislation.
Mr. Speaker, I yield to the gentleman from California (Mr. Cisneros). I believe it was the Army that he served in.
Oh, my God. It was the Navy. He has served as an Assistant Secretary?
Mr. Speaker, I yield to the gentleman from California (Mr. Cisneros), who served as Under Secretary of Defense.
Mr. Speaker, I thank Congressman Cisneros for his comments. We appreciate his service, and we thank him for his service.
Mr. Speaker, I will share as much as I can of a statement that was put out by the Veterans of Foreign Wars. It is titled: “VFW Condemns Cowardly and Dishonorable House Passage of Benefit Cuts on Veterans Day.”
“House shirks accountability and quickly claims to pass controversial and unprecedented benefit cuts by voice vote.”
“On a day dedicated to honoring America's veterans, the House of Representatives took the reprehensible step to quickly pass the so-called Take Care of America's Veterans Act (H.R. 9237), advancing legislation that the Veterans of Foreign Wars of the United States considers the largest net benefit cut since the Great Depression, setting a dangerous precedent that would allow Congress to cut veterans' earned benefits to finance unrelated Federal spending.
“The circumstances surrounding the House's action make this vote even more troubling. After conducting a lengthy recorded roll call vote on another matter, the House moved to a voice vote on TCAVA, with the Chair quickly declaring that the yeas had prevailed without the opportunity for a roll call, while House Veterans' Affairs Committee Ranking Member Mark Takano was called off the floor to discuss amending the bill.
“If that sequence is confirmed”--and I can confirm it--“veterans and the American people deserve an explanation for why Members of Congress were not required to go on the record on legislation that could affect millions of veterans and their families. Veterans deserve to know where their elected Representatives stand. They deserve more than procedural maneuvering that leaves the public questioning whether their Representatives were willing to accept accountability for their votes.
“ `It is an insult to America's veterans that Congress would advance legislation threatening their earned benefits on Veterans Day, the very day our Nation is supposed to honor their service and sacrifice,' said VFW National Commander-in-Chief Cory Geisler. `And if congressional leaders believed this proposal was worthy of passage, they should have had the courage to let every Member's position be recorded for the country to see. Playing political games with veterans benefits while avoiding public accountability is cowardly and dishonorable. Those who have worn the uniform are watching, and we are more than disappointed--we feel dishonored and disrespected for our service. This proposal should be dead on arrival in the Senate, sending an unmistakable message to every American serving in harm's way that this country will honor its commitments to those who defend it.'
“The VFW has repeatedly raised concerns about Section 108 of the legislation, which would, for the first time ever, write changes to the VA disability rating schedule into law to generate budget savings. Beyond its immediate implications for veterans' disability compensation, the VFW believes this approach creates a roadmap for future Congresses to target veterans' earned benefits as a budgetary gimmick or to cut benefits out of political convenience.
[Material placed in the Record (such as bill text, a letter or an article) is not shown here. See the original.]
“The timing of today's vote carries particular significance. As American servicemembers continue to serve in harm's way around the world, Congress has advanced a proposal that raises serious questions about the promises made to those who volunteer to serve.
“ `Our all-volunteer force is built on the promise that when Americans step forward to defend this country, this country will stand behind them,' said Geisler. `We cannot tell young Americans that their service is indispensable while simultaneously treating the benefits earned through that service as a convenient way to cut spending. We must honor the contract, not rewrite it when the bill comes due.'
“More than 150 VFW volunteers converged on Washington this week to make their voices heard, joining thousands more who called and emailed their legislators from communities across the country. Their message was consistent: Veterans' earned benefits should never be used as a congressional piggy bank to fund other projects or as leverage in budget negotiations.
“With the legislation now heading to the Senate, the VFW's concerns are stronger than ever after the political trickery in the House. The organization maintains that Congress can pursue meaningful improvements to veterans' benefits without financing them through reductions to other veterans' compensation or establishing a precedent that threatens future generations of servicemembers.
“The VFW has historically fought against benefit cuts like those included in TCAVA, and we will continue to fight these kinds of dangerous proposals to the end--especially when legislators seek to avoid accountability. VFW will continue to monitor the legislation and communicate its concerns about the potential consequences for veterans, military families, and the Nation's all-volunteer force, ensuring our Nation's leaders honor the contract.”
That is a very powerful statement that was put out by the Veterans of Foreign Wars, the VFW. I thank them for their fierce advocacy on behalf of America's veterans. They have clearly seen through the dishonesty of how the Take Care of America's Veterans Act dishonors our veterans.
Today, this Republican majority chose to use widows and widowers as a wedge to divide the veteran community. Today, while we sit here in this body, sailors are told to prepare for 11-month deployments at sea. After we ask these men and women to do more than we have asked of them since World War II, my colleagues across the aisle think it is a worthy goal to ensure that we should slash their benefits.
This Republican majority has decided to burn it all down on the way out, not because they care about their oath to the Constitution or this country, but solely because they care about themselves and their own pockets.
It was painfully clear today that the majority did not have the votes to pass their egregious cut to veterans benefits, so they did it in the most underhanded way possible instead.
This Republican Party is so morally corrupt, they have to resort to tricks to get their misguided agenda through the House because they knew it would fail if given an honest review.
However, this isn't just some perceived slight to the prerogatives of the House. It is far more serious than that. Make no mistake that what happened today was the Republicans resorting to games to pass the largest cut to veterans benefits in history. It was a cowardly move from a morally bankrupt party that will harm America's veterans.
Our Nation is very fortunate, indeed, to have an all-volunteer force, but in order to have that volunteer force, we must make it worth signing up for. These men and women sign up to go into harm's way and to give their life if it comes down to that.
This Nation asks these servicemembers to miss birthdays, weddings, holidays, and even their own children's births. What does this Nation and this Congress offer in return? We guarantee that when they exit the service, they are guaranteed education, healthcare, housing, disability compensation, and then some.
What this body did today is tell our servicemembers that they are simply pawns in rich men's games. I wonder who would want to serve a country that treats their service like that? Who would want to raise their right hand and put it all on the line if they knew Republicans would just claw back the benefits they were promised because it is politically convenient to them?
If this majority can't do the right thing when everyone is looking, what are they doing behind our backs when no one can see?
This position is a place of public service and of public trust. Public trust. It is not just public trust. It is the trust that we have to have among ourselves as Members of this body, the trust that we have from a sense of fair play.
What we saw today was not a display of fair play. It is clear that the Speaker and this Republican majority have fully forgotten what fair play means.
Remember just last year when they wanted to cut 30,000 jobs at the Veterans Administration? Remember when they tore up the collective bargaining agreements of hardworking VA employees multiple times over? Remember, at least one-third of those employees were veterans themselves.
Remember when they stood behind articles that painted veterans as greedy and getting overly generous benefits? I remember those things, and I am willing to remember that veterans at home remember those things.
I wonder if my colleagues remember the veterans sleeping on the steps of the Capitol to get the PACT Act passed, the high fives that were happening in the Senate when they thought that they had derailed the PACT Act? I certainly do. I certainly do remember.
Why do I remember these things? I remember them because Republicans have repeatedly shown themselves to be spineless when it comes to principles. They do not stand up and do the right thing until they are absolutely forced to do it, absolutely forced to do it.
I go back to this example of having the Major Richard Star Act, which had over 330 sponsors not get a vote in this House until a discharge petition had to be circulated. We had to force them to do the right thing. Even on today, when 33 Republicans joined all the Democrats on the motion to discharge the Major Richard Star Act to the floor today, at the eleventh hour they dropped in the Take Care of America's Veterans Act, which twice had to be pulled back because there were no votes earlier this summer. Suddenly they want to vote on it today? Then they pulled underhanded tactics on the floor to distract everybody and quietly say: All those in favor say “yea,” all those in favor say “no.” Boom, bring the gavel down, and then not even hear the appeals of fair play? Let's have the American people know where your Members stand on this, let's vote on this bill, let's have a roll call vote. No.
Mr. Speaker, I don't think that this is fair, and I think if the American people hear this story, they know that it is not fair. If you all think that this bill is so good, I think you should hold a vote. I think you should allow your Members to record where they stand on this bill.
[Material placed in the Record (such as bill text, a letter or an article) is not shown here. See the original.]
Are they proud of this bill?
Are they as proud of this bill as the chairman and as the Speaker seem to be?
Republicans love to say that they are the party who cares for veterans. They repeatedly have said that they are the party of “fiscal responsibility,” yet under Republican leadership they support the criminalization of homelessness, something that effects the veteran population at an outsized rate. They have ended the VASP program, which has meant that veteran homes were foreclosed upon unnecessarily. They have asked one group of veterans to pay for another group's benefits.
They have also introduced legislation to make it so that claim sharks who steal veterans' benefits from them could charge more and more every year.
At every turn and at every decision point, this majority has chosen the dishonorable route, the unethical route. They have chosen to take for granted those who serve this Nation, and they don't care who knows it.
Actually, let me take that back. They do care who knows it, and that is why they employ the tactics they used today so that their Members would not have to go on Record.
They got theirs, and they don't care about yours.
In the meantime, who pays for the cost of war?
Our veterans do with their health and their livelihoods. That is what gets me about why it has been so hard to get a vote on the Major Richard Star Act, a vote that we are going to get tomorrow.
The Major Richard Star Act costs around $11 billion over 10 years, some say $10 billion, but my point is that roughly 10 days of the Iran war would pay for 10 years of the Major Richard Star Act. It would pay for the ability for us to get 59,000 combat veterans the military pay that they have earned, the military pay that were they were denied because their injuries forced them into retirement before their 20 years could be earned.
Now, we are talking about another $1,200 to $2,000 for these combat veterans who would get their military pay when the Major Richard Star Act is signed into law, and I believe it will be signed into law. However, my Republican colleagues were so focused on the $12 billion that they said was unpaid for that they insisted they would be paid for by other veterans not being able to apply for tinnitus or sleep apnea. They put it on the veterans. They sent the veterans the invoice to pay for their own benefits, when, in reality, the military pay and the retirement pay they should be getting for the service years they put in, the military retirement pay that they earned for their service should be paid for by the Department of Defense. The Republicans have no problem asking for $1 trillion from the Department of Defense not paid for, not offset.
However, they want to make the veterans pay for the $10 billion that the Major Richard Star Act is going to cost, make them pay for their military pay. This is the height of hypocrisy and the height of indifference.
Is there any evidence of whether or not the Republican Party really cares about the grunts who put their lives on the line?
Or will they care more about the billionaires and corporations that got $1 trillion in tax cuts?
This situation today should tell you that, Mr. Speaker.
The Republican value system explains why they fought tooth and nail to keep the Major Richard Star Act from being voted on, even when the will of the House was expressed through a discharge petition that got 218 signatures. Even when the will of the House is being expressed by 33 Republicans crossing over to vote for the motion to discharge the Major Richard Star Act to the floor, the Republican leadership maneuvers in the slyest and most underhanded way to ram TCAVA through the House on Veterans Day, this day of all days.
So who pays for the cost of war?
Our veterans do with their health and livelihood.
Mr. Speaker, the chairman won't have to worry about that. The chairman's house is safe. His benefits have already been decided. He doesn't need to use the GI Bill. Good for him.
But I worry about the 22-year-old infantryman who goes home to rural Nebraska or to Detroit or any one of these United States. I worry that that infantryman is going to struggle to get his education on track or get properly compensated for the injuries sustained in service.
I worry that we have opened Pandora's box and are going to keep chipping away at veterans benefits.
This body loves to make veterans. It loves to send people off to war. And it also loves to screw them over when they come home. It is a little more than ironic that this body would green-light a golden dome with a price tag of $1.2 trillion, it will green-light those permanent tax cuts for the wealthy, and it will talk a big game about a $275 billion Trump-class battleship program, but it will nickel-and-dime the men and women who will serve on it.
Mr. Speaker, I don't know about you, but I don't come to work knowing that I may have to lay my life on the line for an idea that this Nation is a city on a hill, but our veterans just did that, they do that, and they will do that. They signed up, went through grueling training, and gave up certain freedoms, and for what?
Is it so that this body, so this Republican leadership, can use them as pawns?
Is it so we can ship them off to faraway battles that we can't see the hell they are living through?
Even congressional delegations that seek access to the bases to survey the damage and to ask questions about what happened are turned away. This body and this Republican leadership ought to be ashamed of its abdication of its authority. This Chamber has not been an effective check on a deranged President who is sending this Nation's sons and daughters to war all the while planning to return home to less than those who have gone before them.
This Nation voted resoundingly to send these morally corrupt so-called leaders packing, and it cannot be soon enough.
I can't wait to see, Mr. Speaker, that door hit your behind as you leave this institution. Maybe Donald Trump will talk about how fine a behind it is.
[Material placed in the Record (such as bill text, a letter or an article) is not shown here. See the original.]
Just remember: If they will cut benefits from those serving now, it will be easier to make the case to cut benefits from survivors of all our servicemembers.
The path will have already been made to advocate against a VA home loan. I only hope that when your sons and daughters have earned their VA benefits, there are better leaders in place to ensure that, despite your depravity, those who served get their earned benefits.
Tomorrow, we will have the opportunity to do right by our combat-injured veterans. We will finally have the opportunity to vote on the Major Richard Star Act, which will allow veterans to receive both their VA compensation and their full retirement. It is long overdue.
The bill has broad bipartisan support. I hope for our veterans' sake and the soul of this institution that the majority will join Democrats in overwhelmingly voting for this legislation.
I think I have gotten some things off my chest. Let me say how much I thank the veterans who have sacrificed for our country, for all of our freedoms, and how they have made the United States the greatest Nation on Earth.
To all the veterans today, I will do my utmost to make sure that we serve you, that we honor the contract with you, and that we have your back as you put your life on the line for this Nation and its people.
To all of those in harm's way today, I wish you Godspeed. Know that the American people stand behind you. I will hold this body accountable to make sure that we honor the contract we have all made with you.
Mr. Speaker, I yield back the balance of my time.